Part 2 — GED ® Reasoning Through Language Arts · Unit 2 — Identifying and Creating Arguments
Unit 2 — Identifying and Creating Arguments
This unit starts with Assessment Target R.8: judging claims, evidence, and reasoning. Then it uses comparison target R.9.3 and Writing targets W.1 through W.3 to build up to evidence-based analysis and the extended response.
Chapter 7 — R.8: Evaluating Arguments, Claims, and Evidence
GED® test targets: R.8.1, R.8.2, R.8.3, R.8.4, R.8.5, R.8.6
Inside Start — Does the Flyer Prove It?
Fictional practice document; procedures differ by facility.
Program flyer: “The reading tutor program works. Last session, 14 of the 18 learners who finished moved up at least one reading level on the program’s own test.”
Guided: Name the claim and the evidence. What information is missing?
Answer: Claim: the program works. Evidence: 14 of 18 finishers moved up a level. Missing: how many people started but did not finish, and how learners who did not take the program did over the same time. The evidence is relevant but not sufficient for the claim, so you judge it yourself, which is what R.8 asks.
An argument is a reasoned case for a position. A claim is a statement the author wants readers to accept. Evidence is information offered in support. Reasoning explains how the evidence supports the claim.
R.8.1 — Steps of an Argument
Trace the argument from issue to claim, reasons, evidence, reasoning, counterclaim, and conclusion. Not every passage labels these parts, so identify the job each sentence performs.
Practice — Steps of an Argument
Passage: (1) Our town’s library closes at 6:00 p.m. on weekdays. (2) The library should stay open until 8:00 p.m. two nights a week. (3) Many residents work until 5:30 and cannot reach the library before it closes. (4) In a two-month trial at a nearby library, evening visitors filled most computer stations. (5) Some worry about staff costs, but the trial was paid for by moving morning hours, when visits were lowest.
GED-style question: Which sentence states the author’s main claim? A. Sentence 1 B. Sentence 2 C. Sentence 3 D. Sentence 5
Answer: B. Sentence 2 is the position the rest of the passage supports. Sentence 1 is background, sentence 3 is a reason, and sentence 5 answers a counterclaim.
R.8.2 — Identifying Evidence Supporting Claims or Conclusions
Select facts, examples, data, or testimony that directly make a claim more credible.
R.8.3 — Evaluating Relevance and Sufficiency
Relevant evidence addresses the claim; sufficient evidence is enough in scope, quantity, and variety.
R.8.4 — Distinguishing Supported and Unsupported Claims
Separate conclusions justified by evidence from assertions that sound certain but exceed or lack support.
R.8.5 — Valid and Fallacious Reasoning
Evaluate whether conclusions follow logically and identify flaws such as false choice, personal attack, circular reasoning, or hasty generalization.
R.8.6 — Identifying Underlying Premises and Assumptions
State the unstated idea an argument requires. Test what happens if that premise is false.
Practice — R.8.2: Identifying Evidence Supporting Claims or Conclusions
First locate the claim. Then test each fact or example by asking: If this detail is true, does it make the claim more believable? Relevant evidence connects directly to the claim.
Claim: The city should extend library hours on two evenings. Evidence: During a three-month trial, evening computer use averaged 92 percent of available stations, and most users reported employment or coursework needs.
Think it through: Which evidence best supports the claim?
Answer: the trial’s high evening computer use and stated needs. A detail about the library’s roof repair would be true but irrelevant.
Practice — R.8.3: Evaluating Relevance and Sufficiency
One relevant story may illustrate a problem without proving how common it is.
Claim: A training program improves job retention. Evidence A: one graduate kept a job for a year. Evidence B: records show 74 percent of 240 graduates remained employed for at least one year, compared with 51 percent of similar applicants who did not attend.
Think it through: Why is B stronger?
Answer: it remains relevant while using a much larger sample, a comparison group, and a measurable outcome.
Practice — R.8.4: Distinguishing Supported and Unsupported Claims
A supported claim has enough relevant evidence to justify confidence. An unsupported assertion may sound certain but lacks proof. Watch for claims built on one example, vague phrases such as everyone knows, or conclusions that go beyond the data.
Assertion: “Longer library hours will eliminate unemployment.” The evening-use evidence does not support that claim. It may support improved access to job-search tools, which is narrower and defensible.
Think it through: Which revision makes the claim fit the evidence?
Answer: “Longer evening hours would give more residents access to job-search computers.”
Practice — R.8.5: Valid and Fallacious Reasoning
A fallacy is a flaw in reasoning. Common examples include false choice, personal attack, slippery slope, circular reasoning, hasty generalization, and confusing sequence with cause.
Statement: “Either we approve this exact plan or we do not care about safety.” This is a false choice because other safety plans may exist.
Think it through: Why is the reasoning weak?
Answer: it reduces several possible responses to only two and treats disagreement as not caring about safety rather than comparing options.
Practice — R.8.6: Identifying Underlying Premises and Assumptions
An assumption is an unstated idea an argument depends on. If the assumption fails, the reasoning may weaken. State the hidden bridge between evidence and conclusion.
Argument: The parking lot is full at noon, so the building needs a larger lot. Assumption: the cars belong to people using the building and the demand is regular rather than caused by a temporary event.
Think it through: Which fact would most weaken the argument?
Answer: a neighboring festival used the lot on the day it was observed.
Additional Tool — Evaluating Evidence Types and Sources
Common evidence includes facts, statistics, examples, expert testimony, observations, and research findings. Evaluate source expertise, sample size, method, date, possible bias, and whether the reasoning confuses correlation with causation.
A survey of 40 volunteers on a fitness website cannot confidently represent every adult in a state. The source population is narrow and self-selected.
Think it through: What is the main limitation?
Answer: the sample may not represent the broader population.
Additional Tool — Evaluating Source Credibility
Credibility is trustworthiness for the particular claim. Consider expertise, direct access to information, transparency, corroboration, date, and conflicts of interest. A credible source can still make an error; credibility increases confidence but does not replace evidence.
For a claim about regional water quality, a current laboratory report with methods and sample locations is generally stronger than an unsigned social-media post claiming the water “looks fine.”
Think it through: Which source is most credible for the chemical claim?
Answer: the report, because it provides relevant testing, methods, and traceable evidence.
Additional Tool — Evaluating Data, Graphs, and Visual Evidence
Visual evidence must be read as critically as prose. Check title, axes, units, scale, categories, time period, and source. A truncated axis can exaggerate a small difference.
A bar graph begins its vertical axis at 90 rather than zero, making values of 96 and 98 appear dramatically different. The numerical difference remains two units.
Think it through: What feature may mislead readers?
Answer: the restricted axis visually magnifies a small difference.
Reinforcement — Comparing Evidence Across Related Arguments
When two authors discuss the same issue, build an evidence map: each claim, each reason, the evidence offered, source quality, missing information, and how directly the reasoning connects.
Author A supports remote work using a company survey of productivity and retention. Author B opposes it using examples of collaboration problems from three managers. A has broader data; B raises a relevant concern but offers a smaller evidence base.
Think it through: Which argument is better supported?
Answer: A, if the survey methods are sound, because its evidence is broader and directly measures outcomes. This does not prove B’s concern is false.
How the GED® Test Checks R.8
Questions may ask for a claim, relevant evidence, an assumption, a weakness, a credible source, or the stronger argument. Eliminate answers that state your opinion without analyzing support.
Common Mistakes
Do not confuse a reason with evidence. “This policy is fair” is a claim, not proof. Do not choose an argument because you agree with its conclusion. Do not reject emotional examples automatically; ask whether they are representative and connected.
What You Need to Remember
Strong arguments make clear claims, use relevant and sufficient credible evidence, and connect that evidence through sound reasoning.
Independent Practice — Chapter 7
Cover the answers while you work. (Inside) items are fictional; the others use outside settings, like the test.
1. (Inside) A flyer says, “Everyone who takes the typing class gets a job after release.” What is the main problem with this claim? A. It is too specific. B. It attacks a person. C. It uses statistics incorrectly. D. It is an absolute claim with no evidence.
2. Argument: “The town should ban fireworks because my neighbor’s dog was scared last July.” What kind of evidence is used? A. A large study B. A single anecdote C. Expert testimony D. Comparative data
3. Argument: “If we let students use calculators in class, soon they will forget how to count, and the whole school system will fail.” Which fallacy is this? A. Slippery slope B. Personal attack C. Circular reasoning D. Appeal to authority
4. Argument: “Our store’s sales fell after we moved the entrance, so the new entrance caused the drop.” What assumption does the argument depend on? A. Sales never change. B. Customers prefer side entrances. C. Nothing else changed at the same time that could explain the drop. D. The store should close.
Answer Check — Chapter 7
1. D. “Everyone” is absolute, and the flyer gives no evidence. A, B and C do not describe it. 2. B. One dog on one night is an anecdote. A, C and D are not present. 3. A. Each step leads to a bigger, unsupported consequence. B, C and D are other fallacies. 4. C. If a holiday, a competitor or road work also changed, the conclusion fails. A, B and D are not required by the argument.