Part 2 — GED ® Reasoning Through Language Arts · Unit 2 — Identifying and Creating Arguments
Chapter 8 — R.9.3: Comparing Arguments on the Same Topic
GED® test targets: R.9.3
Inside Start — Two Suggestions on the Suggestion Form
Fictional practice document; procedures differ by facility.
Suggestion 1: “Keep the dayroom TV on the news in the evening. On last week’s sign-up sheet, 31 of 40 people chose news.” Suggestion 2: “Rotate channels. A lot of people say they never get to watch sports.”
Guided: Both writers want a fair TV plan. How does their evidence differ?
Answer: Suggestion 1 uses a tally from a sign-up sheet. Suggestion 2 uses unspecified complaints (“a lot of people say”). The first gives measurable evidence; the second raises a real concern without measuring it.
R.9.3 asks you to compare two argumentative texts and analyze how each uses evidence and interpretation.
Understanding the Skill
Two authors may agree on facts but disagree about meaning or policy. They may use different evidence, emphasize different consequences, or interpret the same data differently.
Seeing It in Action
Author A: A city should convert one traffic lane into a bus lane because buses carry more people per vehicle and travel times improved 16 percent during a pilot. Author B: The lane should remain open to all traffic because nearby small businesses reported delivery delays during the same pilot.
Agreement: transportation efficiency matters. Difference: A prioritizes passenger movement; B prioritizes delivery access. Evidence: A uses travel-time data; B uses business reports. A complete comparison does not pretend one set of evidence answers every concern.
GED-Style Application
Think it through: Which statement best compares the arguments?
Answer: Both address transportation effects, but A relies on systemwide travel data while B emphasizes reported effects on a specific group.
Comparing Stronger and Weaker Support
Judge support, not popularity. Consider whether the evidence is measurable, representative, current, independently verifiable, and directly connected. Also notice whether an author addresses counterevidence.
Common Mistakes
Do not write that the authors “talk about the same thing” and stop. Name the claims, evidence, reasoning, and meaningful difference. Do not assume compromise is automatically correct.
What You Need to Remember
Comparison requires parallel analysis: claim against claim, evidence against evidence, and reasoning against reasoning.
Independent Practice — Chapter 8
Cover the answers while you work. (Inside) items are fictional; the others use outside settings, like the test.
Use these two short arguments for items 1–3. Author 1: “The county should add a night clinic. In a survey of 600 residents, 42 percent said they had skipped care because the clinic closed before they got off work.” Author 2: “A night clinic would cost too much. I have never seen a line at the clinic, so demand must be low.”
1. On what do the authors disagree? A. Whether the county has a clinic B. Whether surveys are legal C. Whether residents work D. Whether a night clinic is needed and worth the cost
2. Which statement best compares their evidence? A. Both use surveys. B. Author 1 uses survey data; Author 2 uses personal observation. C. Author 2 uses cost figures. D. Neither offers evidence.
3. Which argument is better supported? A. Author 1, because the survey is broader and directly measures unmet need B. Author 2, because cost always matters most C. Author 2, because personal experience is more reliable D. Neither, because they disagree
Answer Check — Chapter 8
1. D. Both know a clinic exists; they disagree about adding night hours. 2. B. A and C are untrue; D ignores both sources. 3. A. Note that Author 2 mentions cost but gives no figures, and “no line” during the hours the clinic is open cannot measure people who cannot come during those hours. B and C are unsupported preferences; D confuses disagreement with lack of evidence.