Part 2 — GED ® Reasoning Through Language Arts · Unit 2 — Identifying and Creating Arguments
Chapter 9 — W.1: Creating Arguments and Using Evidence
GED® test targets: W.1 (scored on the extended response under Trait 1)
Inside Start — Making a Request Form Argue
Fictional practice document; procedures differ by facility.
A first draft on a request form: “I want to get in the GED class because I need it.”
Guided: Revise the sentence into a clear claim with evidence.
Answer: One strong revision: “I am requesting a seat in the GED class because I have finished the reading foundations book and I need the credential to qualify for vocational training.” It states the claim, then gives specific, checkable reasons.
Writing Target W.1 (official wording): “Determine the details of what is explicitly stated and make logical inferences or valid claim that square with textual evidence.” On the extended response, this skill is scored under Trait 1, Creation of Arguments and Use of Evidence. Your task is analytical, not a personal-opinion essay.
Developing a Clear Claim
A written claim answers the prompt and controls the response. For a paired-argument task, a useful claim identifies which author is better supported and gives the main reason for that judgment.
Weak thesis: “Both articles have good points.” Strong thesis: “The first author presents the better-supported argument because the evidence is broader, directly measures the claimed outcome, and addresses a likely objection.”
GED-style task: Revise “I agree with Author A” into an analytical claim. Better: “Author A’s position is better supported by comparative data and a clearer explanation of how the proposal would affect costs.”
Using Relevant Evidence From Source Texts
Evidence may be quoted briefly, paraphrased accurately, or summarized. Use only information from the supplied passages unless the prompt permits outside knowledge. Select evidence that helps evaluate support, not merely evidence that repeats the topic.
Source fact: “During the pilot, injury reports declined from 31 to 18.” Accurate paraphrase: The pilot was associated with thirteen fewer reported injuries. Do not write that injuries disappeared.
Think it through: Which evidence best supports a judgment about safety? Choose injury data over a sentence describing the program’s logo or launch date.
Explaining the Connection Between Evidence and Claim
Evidence does not speak for itself. Commentary explains why the fact matters, what it demonstrates, and how it affects the comparison.
Evidence: Author B cites delivery delays reported by nearby small businesses. Explanation: Those reports identify a possible delivery problem, but the passage gives no count of businesses or measured delay times, which makes them weaker than the measured 16 percent travel-time improvement Author A reports.
A reliable body-paragraph pattern is claim, evidence, explanation, comparison, and link back to the thesis.
Addressing Counterclaims
A counterclaim is an opposing position. Addressing it shows you understand the debate. You may acknowledge a valid concern, then explain why the opposing author’s support is limited or why the stronger evidence still outweighs it.
Example: Author B correctly notes that deliveries matter to small businesses. However, the passage provides no delivery-time records, while Author A reports a measured 16 percent travel-time improvement.
Common Mistakes
Do not choose based on personal agreement. Do not copy long sections of the sources. Do not list evidence without explanation. Do not invent facts, experts, or statistics.
What You Need to Remember
Make a defensible claim, use accurate source evidence, and explain why that evidence supports your evaluation.
Independent Practice — Chapter 9
Cover the answers while you work. (Inside) items are fictional; the others use outside settings, like the test.
1. (Inside) Which sentence is the strongest claim for a request form? A. “I need this.” B. “This is not fair.” C. “I am requesting a transfer to the morning work assignment so I can attend the afternoon GED class.” D. “Everybody else got moved.”
2. Source sentence: “After the change, complaints fell from 40 to 25.” Which paraphrase is accurate? A. Complaints disappeared. B. Complaints rose. C. Complaints fell by half. D. Complaints fell by 15.
3. Which sentence best explains how evidence supports a claim? A. “Author A has statistics.” B. “Author A reports a 20 percent drop in late deliveries across all routes, which directly measures the problem Author B only describes.” C. “Author A is right.” D. “Statistics are always better.”
Answer Check — Chapter 9
1. C. It is specific and gives a reason. A, B and D are vague or unsupported. 2. D. 40 − 25 = 15. A and B are false; C is wrong because half of 40 is 20. 3. B. It names the evidence and explains why it matters. A lists without explaining; C and D are unsupported judgments.