Part 2 — GED ® Reasoning Through Language Arts · Unit 2 — Identifying and Creating Arguments
Chapter 12 — The GED® Extended Response
GED® test targets: W.1, W.2, W.3 (extended response, Traits 1–3); supports R.8.3 and R.9.3
Inside Start — The Dayroom Debate
You have heard this argument before. One person says the unit should use a sign-up sheet for the dayroom TV and points to how many people signed up last time. Another says, “Everybody knows the sheet doesn’t work.” You do not have to like either person to decide which one gave you more to go on. That judgment is the whole extended response: which argument is better supported, and how do you know? The practice passages in this chapter are set outside the facility, as the test will be.
The RLA extended response gives you 45 minutes to read two argumentative passages, determine which argument is better supported, and write an evidence-based analysis. You are not asked which position you personally prefer. On the test, the two extended response passages together run about 550–650 words and never more than 650. [Assessment Guide, pp. 86, 97] The examples in this chapter are short so you can learn the steps; the full-length practice at the end of the chapter is test length.
The Three Scoring Traits
Trait 1, Creation of Arguments and Use of Evidence, evaluates your analytical claim, selection of relevant source evidence, and explanation of how evidence supports the analysis. Trait 2, Development of Ideas and Organizational Structure, evaluates focus, logical progression, paragraph development, transitions, and a formal style and appropriate tone. Trait 3, Clarity and Command of Standard English Conventions, evaluates sentence clarity, grammar, usage, punctuation, and mechanics.
A response can have correct grammar and still be weak if it does not analyze evidence. A response can have strong ideas and still lose clarity through repeated sentence errors. Treat all three traits as connected. Each trait is scored 0–2, for 6 points total, and that score is double-weighted so the extended response counts as up to 12 raw points on the RLA test. [Assessment Guide for Educators, Oct. 2020, p. 92]
A 45-Minute Plan
Minutes 0–8: read the prompt and both passages, marking claims, evidence, reasoning, and weaknesses. Minutes 8–12: choose the better-supported argument and build a short plan. Minutes 12–37: draft the response. Minutes 37–45: revise for task completion, organization, evidence accuracy, explanation, and conventions.
The times are a working plan, not a rule that requires you to stop mid-sentence. Protect revision time. A finished draft with a clear thesis and supported analysis is stronger than an elaborate introduction followed by an unfinished response.
Original Paired Passage A — Keep the Late Bus
The city should continue the Route 14 bus until midnight. During the six-month late-service pilot, average weeknight ridership after 10:00 p.m. rose from 38 riders to 71 riders. Transit records show that 64 percent of those riders boarded near hospitals, warehouses, and restaurants where shifts end after regular service. The pilot cost $148,000, but fare revenue covered about one-third of that amount.
Late service also improved access for workers who do not own cars. In a survey sent to every rider who used a registered fare card during the pilot, 312 of 486 respondents said they had previously paid for rides, walked long distances, or declined late shifts. Critics note that the service requires a subsidy. Public transit, however, is designed to connect residents to work and essential services, not to earn a profit on every route. The city should keep the service and review ridership after another year.
Original Paired Passage B — End the Late Bus Pilot
The Route 14 late-service pilot should end. The city cannot continue every program that benefits some residents. The two late buses often appeared nearly empty when I drove beside them, and several taxpayers have complained about paying for service they never use. The $148,000 pilot cost could instead repair damaged bus shelters or improve daytime reliability.
Supporters point to a rider survey, but people who already use late service are likely to favor keeping it. The city should focus on routes used by the greatest number of people. If late-shift employers need transportation for their workers, those businesses should arrange it. Ending the pilot would allow the transit agency to spend limited funds on needs that affect more residents.
Step 1 — Identify Each Central Argument
Passage A claims the city should keep late Route 14 service because measured ridership and survey evidence show that it connects late-shift workers to employment. Passage B claims the pilot should end because the service is costly and limited funds could serve more riders elsewhere.
Step 2 — Evaluate Evidence and Reasoning
Passage A uses route records, boarding locations, cost and revenue figures, and a survey with a stated response count. The evidence directly addresses use, purpose, and cost. Its survey may contain response bias, but the ridership records do not depend on opinion.
Passage B raises a relevant opportunity-cost argument: money spent late cannot be spent elsewhere. However, its main ridership evidence is personal observation—buses appeared empty—and unspecified taxpayer complaints. It proposes other uses for funds but provides no cost estimates, ridership comparisons, or evidence that employers can supply transportation.
Step 3 — Choose the Better-Supported Argument
Passage A is better supported. This judgment does not require believing that late service must continue forever. It means A provides more relevant, measurable, and transparent evidence for its position than B provides for ending the service.
Step 4 — Build the Plan
Thesis: Passage A is better supported because it uses measured ridership and employment-access evidence, while Passage B depends heavily on anecdote and unsupported alternatives. Body paragraph 1: compare ridership evidence. Body paragraph 2: compare cost reasoning and limitations. Conclusion: restate the evidence-based judgment.
Annotated Model Response
Passage A presents the better-supported argument about the Route 14 pilot. Although both authors recognize that the city has limited funds, Passage A uses measurable evidence to show who uses the service and why, while Passage B relies mainly on personal observation and unmeasured alternatives.
First, Passage A supports its ridership claim with transit records. Weeknight ridership after 10:00 increased from 38 to 71, and nearly two-thirds of late riders boarded near businesses with late shifts. These details connect the service directly to employment access. Passage B says the buses “appeared nearly empty” when the author drove beside them. That observation may describe a few moments, but it cannot measure total riders across six months. The transit records are therefore more representative and relevant.
Passage A also addresses cost more fully. It states the total pilot cost and notes that fares covered about one-third. The author then explains why a subsidy may still be justified by public access. Passage B reasonably argues that the money could be used for shelters or daytime reliability, but it gives no figures showing what those projects would cost or how many riders they would help. Without that comparison, the alternative remains possible rather than demonstrated.
Passage A is not perfect. Its rider survey may favor the views of people who use the service. Still, the author combines that survey with independent ridership and boarding-location records. Passage B identifies a real budget concern but does not support the claim that other uses would benefit more residents. For that reason, Passage A offers the stronger evidence and reasoning.
Why the Model Works
The introduction answers the task and states reasons. Each body paragraph compares the passages rather than merely summarizing them. Evidence is accurate and followed by explanation. The response acknowledges a limitation in Passage A, which strengthens fairness, and identifies the unsupported step in Passage B. The conclusion is integrated into the final analytical paragraph without repeating the opening word for word.
A Weak Response and How to Repair It
Weak response: “I think buses are important because people need jobs. Passage A has statistics, so it is obviously right. Passage B is selfish.” This response relies on personal belief, gives no specific evidence, fails to analyze the statistics, and attacks the author.
Repair: replace personal agreement with a comparative thesis; identify specific ridership and cost evidence; explain representativeness and relevance; describe Passage B’s limitation without insulting the writer.
Writing Introductions
A useful introduction can be three sentences: identify the shared issue, name the better-supported passage, and state two reasons. Avoid a long history of the topic. The scorers need your analysis, not a dramatic opening about “the beginning of time.”
Building Body Paragraphs
Begin with a comparative point. Present precise evidence from one or both sources. Explain quality and connection. Address a weakness or counterpoint when useful. End by linking the comparison to the thesis.
Writing Conclusions
A conclusion should sum up the analysis you have already made. Do not introduce new evidence. Restate the judgment in fresh language and identify the main basis for it.
Using Source Language
Brief quotation can preserve an important phrase, but paraphrase is often more efficient. Whether quoting or paraphrasing, represent the source accurately. You do not need formal citation styles unless the test interface instructs otherwise; identify the passage or author clearly.
Revision Checklist
Did I answer which argument is better supported? Did I evaluate both passages? Did I use specific evidence? Did I explain the evidence? Are paragraphs organized by reasons? Are quotations accurate? Are sentences complete? Did I correct repeated grammar and punctuation errors?
Digital and Printed Practice
On the computer, you will type in a response box and may scroll between sources and your draft. In print practice, keep the passages beside the draft rather than turning the task into a memory test. The reasoning is the same in either format.
What You Need to Remember
The extended response rewards evidence-based evaluation. Choose the better-supported argument, prove your judgment from the passages, explain your reasoning, organize it clearly, and revise.
Independent Extended Response Practice
Write this one alone, in 45 minutes, on separate paper. Do not look at the model response while you write. Afterward, score yourself with the Revision Checklist and the 2-1-0 lines after the prompt. Then read the sample answer and compare.
Original Passage A — Keep School Libraries Open in Summer (fictional). The district should keep three school libraries open two days a week during summer. In a two-summer trial, 1,140 students borrowed at least one book, and reading scores of trial participants fell an average of 2 points over the summer, compared with 7 points for similar students who did not use the libraries. The trial cost $36,000 per summer, less than one percent of the district’s library budget.
Original Passage B — Close the Libraries in Summer (fictional). Summer library hours are a luxury. Families can use the public library downtown. When I visited one of the trial libraries last July, only a few children were there. The money would be better spent on new computers that every student can use during the school year.
Prompt: In your response, analyze both passages to determine which position is better supported. Use relevant and specific evidence from both sources to support your response.
Score Yourself — What 2, 1 and 0 Look Like
Score each trait 2, 1 or 0. Many first tries get a 1 on some traits. That is normal; the lines tell you what to fix next.
Trait 1 — Argument and evidence. 2: You clearly say which passage is better supported, you use specific details from both passages, and you explain why that evidence is strong or weak. 1: You take a side and use some evidence, but your explanation is thin, or some of your support does not come from the passages. 0: There is no clear claim, or there is little or no evidence from the passages.
Trait 2 — Ideas and organization. 2: Your main points are explained, not just listed. They come in a sensible order, with paragraphs and transition words, and your tone is serious and respectful. 1: Some points are explained and others are only listed, or the order jumps around. 0: The ideas are not explained, there is no clear order, or the tone does not fit the task.
Trait 3 — Clear standard English. 2: Your sentences are mostly complete and clear. A few mistakes are fine if they do not get in the way of the meaning. 1: Some sentences are choppy, run on, or awkward, and mistakes sometimes make the meaning hard to follow. 0: Mistakes are so frequent that the meaning is hard to understand.
A response that is blank, off topic, or only copied from the passages scores 0. These lines put the GED® test’s official rubric into plain words. [Assessment Guide for Educators, RLA extended response rubric]
Sample Answer — Summer Libraries
Read this only after you have written and scored your own.
Passage A gives the better-supported argument about summer school libraries. It uses numbers from a two-summer trial, while Passage B relies mostly on one visit and an opinion.
Passage A reports that 1,140 students borrowed at least one book. It also compares reading scores: students in the trial lost an average of 2 points over the summer, while similar students who did not use the libraries lost 7. That comparison suggests the libraries helped, although it does not prove they were the only reason. Passage B says only a few children were there when the author visited one library last July. One visit to one library cannot show how many students used three libraries over two summers.
Passage B makes a fair point that money spent on summer hours cannot be spent on new computers. However, it gives no cost for the computers and no evidence that families can get to the downtown library. Passage A states its cost, $36,000 a summer, and shows that it is less than one percent of the district’s library budget. Because Passage A measures both its results and its cost, it is better supported.
Why it scores 2s: the first paragraph answers the prompt; each body paragraph compares the two passages with exact details; the writer explains why one visit is weak evidence and admits a limit in Passage A; and the sentences are clear and complete. It is shorter than a full test answer, which is fine for practice.
Full-Length Practice — Test-Length Passages
The library passages were short so you could learn the steps. The real test gives you more to read. These two passages together run about 600 words, the length the GED® test uses. [GED Assessment Guide for Educators, Oct. 2020, pp. 86, 97, 99]
Give yourself 45 minutes and follow the 45-Minute Plan: read, plan, write, check. Type it if you can get computer time; paper works too. If the reading takes you a while, that is fine. Speed comes with practice, and now the length on test day won’t surprise you.
Passage A — Give Every Applicant a Fair First Look (fictional)
The city of Marlow should stop asking about criminal convictions on the first page of its job applications. The question would not disappear; it would move. Under the plan, the city would still run a background check, but only after an interview and a job offer that depends on the check.
The city already has evidence about what this change does. From January 2021 to June 2022, Marlow tried the plan for eighteen months in its parks and sanitation departments. Before the trial, about 4 percent of applicants who checked the conviction box were invited to interview. During the trial, 11 percent of applicants who later reported a conviction reached an interview, and 52 of them were hired. One year after hiring, 46 of those 52 workers were still on the job, a rate of 88 percent. For all other new hires in the same two departments, the rate was 84 percent. The trial was small, so the plan also calls for the city to keep tracking these numbers for three more years.
The trial did not lower safety standards. Jobs that involve children, cash, or driving city vehicles still required a full check before any offer, as state law requires. Human resources staff reported that moving the check later added about two days to each hire.
There is also a cost to doing nothing. Marlow has 140 open city jobs, and last year the sanitation department paid $310,000 in overtime to cover routes that had no driver. According to the county court office, about one in three adults in the county has an arrest or conviction record. When a checkbox screens out those applicants before anyone reads their work history, the city loses workers it badly needs.
The plan asks for something simple: look at a person’s skills first and their record second. The trial shows that this order fills jobs, keeps workers, and leaves in place the rules that protect the public. The city council should adopt the plan for every department.
Passage B — Keep the Question on the Application (fictional)
The city of Marlow should keep asking about convictions on its job applications. Employers deserve honest information at the start, not after hours of interviews.
Supporters of the change point to a trial in two departments. But two departments are not the whole city. An eighteen-month trial cannot tell us what will happen over ten years. The workers hired during a well-publicized experiment may also have tried harder because they knew people were watching.
Moving the question later wastes everyone’s time. A hiring manager may interview several people, choose one, and then learn about a record that rules the person out. The manager has to start over, and the applicant’s hopes are raised and then crushed. It is kinder to be clear from the beginning.
The city could also face lawsuits. If a worker with a record hurts someone on the job, the injured person could sue the city for careless hiring, and taxpayers would pay the bill. A checkbox at the start protects the city from that risk.
Many residents feel strongly about this issue. At a council meeting last spring, several speakers said they would not feel safe knowing that city workers had not been screened. A neighbor of mine who owns a bakery told me she always asks about records because she has been burned before.
Finally, the city has other ways to fill open jobs. It could raise starting pay, advertise in more places, or offer signing bonuses. Those steps would bring in more applicants without asking taxpayers to accept unknown risks. The council should reject the proposal and keep the application as it is.
Prompt (full-length practice): In your response, analyze both passages to determine which position is better supported. Use relevant and specific evidence from both sources to support your response. You have 45 minutes.
After You Score Yourself — What a Strong Response Notices
Score your response with the 2-1-0 lines first. Then see which of these points you caught. You don’t need every one to score well. You need a clear choice and the evidence to back it.
Passage A’s evidence: numbers from before and during the trial (4 percent of applicants with a record reached an interview before, 11 percent during), how many were hired (52) and stayed a year (46, or 88 percent, against 84 percent for other new hires), the cost of empty jobs ($310,000 in overtime), and the fact that jobs with children, cash, or city vehicles still get a full check before any offer.
Passage A’s limit: it is one small trial, in two departments, for eighteen months. Passage A admits this and plans to keep tracking. A strong response can name this limit and still choose A.
Passage B’s fair point: a short trial in two departments cannot prove what will happen across the whole city over many years.
Passage B’s weak spots: “tried harder because people were watching” is a guess with no evidence. The lawsuit worry and the speakers’ fear that workers “had not been screened” skip over the fact that the plan still runs a background check before anyone is hired. The bakery story is one person’s experience. The other ideas (higher pay, more ads, bonuses) come with no costs or results.
A thesis that works: “Passage A is better supported because it measures what happened when the city tried the plan, while Passage B relies on guesses, one story, and fears the plan already answers.”
If you chose B: scorers can credit either choice when it is backed by evidence from the passages, so your work still counts. Here, though, B is hard to defend. Count how many of B’s points have numbers or records behind them, then compare that with A.