Part 3 — GED ® Science · Unit 3 — Inheritance and Change Across Generations
Chapter 13 — Evolution and the Evidence for Common Ancestry
GED® test targets: L.f.1, L.f.2, L.f.3, SP.4.a, SP.5.a
Suppose maintenance replaces a pale yard surface with a dark one in a fictional observation. Some insects already blend into the new background better than others. Nobody handed the insects a camouflage request form. Natural selection starts with existing variation and differences in survival or reproduction, not an organism wishing hard enough to change its DNA. That wishful version is memorable, simple, and wrong as hell.
Evolution is change in inherited characteristics of populations across generations. Individual organisms grow, learn, and respond to conditions, but a population evolves. A person getting stronger through training is not the same process as inherited variants becoming more common over generations.
Natural selection needs a particular chain
Natural selection occurs when heritable variation affects survival or reproduction in a particular environment. Organisms vary. Some variation is inherited. Conditions influence which variants leave more offspring. Over generations, the frequencies of those variants can change.
Fitness in this context concerns reproductive success in a particular environment, not physical strength or human worth. The biggest organism does not automatically win. A small organism that leaves more surviving offspring may have greater fitness under the conditions being studied.
Selection pressure is an environmental factor affecting survival or reproduction, such as predation, drought, or an antimicrobial exposure. An adaptation is an inherited characteristic shaped by selection that contributes to success in a particular setting. Adaptation is not an organism making a conscious improvement request.
Follow a population through a change
In a simplified insect population, dark and light coloration are inherited. Birds more readily detect insects that contrast with the background. Researchers record these constructed counts before and after a period on a dark background.
| Color | Initial count | Survivors before reproduction |
|---|---|---|
| Dark | 50 | 40 |
| Light | 50 | 10 |
Dark insects had 40/50 = 80% survival; light insects had 10/50 = 20%. Among the survivors, dark insects made up 40/50 = 80%. If the surviving insects reproduce and coloration is inherited, dark coloration may become more common in later generations. The table shows differential survival; the inheritance and reproduction conditions are needed to connect that pattern to evolution.
The insects did not darken because they understood the assignment. The initial population already contained variation. Conditions affected which variants survived. Mutation, gene flow, and genetic drift can also change populations, so natural selection is not the only mechanism of evolution.
Artificial selection and speciation
Artificial selection occurs when humans influence which organisms reproduce based on chosen traits, as in selective breeding of crops. It uses heritable variation, but the selection criterion comes from human choices. A selected trait can bring tradeoffs; a crop bred for one feature is not automatically best in every environment.
Speciation is the formation of distinct species. In many cases, populations become separated, accumulate differences, and eventually become reproductively isolated. Reproductive isolation means gene exchange between the populations is limited or prevented by biological barriers. Geographic separation can contribute, but separation alone does not instantly create a new species.
The biological species concept emphasizes interbreeding and reproductive isolation, but it does not fit every organism or fossil equally well. Scientific categories have uses and limits. You do not need to pretend a useful concept answers every edge case to use it correctly.
Common ancestry leaves multiple kinds of evidence
Fossils document organisms and changes through time. Similar underlying anatomical structures can reflect inheritance from a shared ancestor even when their present functions differ. DNA sequence similarities provide another line of evidence. Developmental patterns and geographic distributions can also support evolutionary relationships.
A cladogram is a branching diagram showing hypothesized relationships. A branch point represents a common ancestor. Organisms sharing a more recent branch point are more closely related in that diagram. Left-to-right position is not a ladder from “primitive” to “advanced,” and rotating branches around a node does not change the relationships.

B and C share a more recent common ancestor with each other than with A. Branch lengths are not a time scale in this diagram.
In this simplified diagram, B and C share a more recent common ancestor with each other than either shares with A. If B is drawn higher than C, that placement does not make B superior. The connection pattern is the information. Branch length represents time or amount of change only if the diagram’s key says so.
Worked evolution question
Question: Which statement best explains the insect results? A. Birds caused every light insect to mutate into a dark insect. B. All surviving insects must have identical DNA. C. Dark insects will be favored in every possible environment. D. Dark coloration was associated with greater survival on the dark background.
Answer: D. The survival proportions support that association in the stated conditions. A invents a directed mutation process and contradicts the surviving light insects. C ignores environmental dependence. B confuses one shared trait with complete genetic identity.
A second question asks what evidence could challenge the camouflage explanation. If birds could not distinguish the colors under the study conditions, or if the two groups differed in a separate survival-relevant trait, the proposed mechanism would need further testing. Evidence that challenges an explanation is valuable; science is not a loyalty contest.
This pulls the last three chapters together. DNA carries inherited information, reproduction reshuffles it, mutation can introduce new variants, and environmental conditions influence which variants persist. Evolution explains population change through these relationships, not through a plan that organisms consciously follow.
Selection Changes Populations, Not Intentions
Follow the mechanism in order. Individuals vary. Some differences are heritable. Environmental conditions affect which individuals leave more surviving offspring. Their inherited variants become more frequent over generations. Remove heritability from that chain and a temporary survival difference need not produce an inherited population change. Remove differential reproduction and the observed difference may have little evolutionary consequence.
Fitness means reproductive success in a particular environment, not physical strength or overall superiority. An inconspicuous insect can have higher fitness than a powerful conspicuous one if predators eat the conspicuous insects before they reproduce. A trait can also carry a cost: heavy protection may improve defense but require resources. Selection concerns the net reproductive consequences under actual conditions.
Mutation introduces new variants without anticipating what organisms need. Genetic drift changes variant frequencies through chance, especially in small populations. Gene flow moves variants when organisms or gametes move between populations. Natural selection is therefore not the only process changing populations. If a storm randomly removes most organisms, the survivors’ allele frequencies can differ without the surviving alleles having caused survival.
Common ancestry is supported by converging evidence: DNA similarities, homologous structures, fossil sequences, and geographic patterns. Homologous structures share an evolutionary origin even when their functions differ. Similar function alone can result from convergent evolution; a useful design can evolve independently. An evolutionary tree marks relationships of descent, not a ladder from “crappy” organisms to superior ones.
When an unfamiliar passage reports a frequency increase, distinguish evidence for change from evidence for its mechanism. A rise from 20% to 60% is a 40-percentage-point increase, but the numbers alone do not prove selection. Evidence that carriers left more offspring under the relevant conditions strengthens that explanation. The GED reasoning move is to connect inherited variation, environment, and reproduction without inventing a plan behind them.
Your Turn — Guided and Independent Practice — Practice Check S13
Guided: In a bacterial population, a resistance variant already exists before antibiotic exposure. Explain how antibiotic use can change variant frequencies through natural selection.
Guided answer: The antibiotic creates a selective pressure. Susceptible bacteria are less likely to survive and reproduce, while resistant bacteria leave more descendants. The population becomes more resistant across generations; individual bacteria do not decide to mutate because they need help.
Independent: Which evidence most directly supports common ancestry? A. One animal is stronger. B. Two species live in the same cage. C. Shared DNA sequences and homologous structures. D. Every organism looks identical.
Independent answer: C. Multiple independent similarities can fit descent with modification. B only shows location, A is a comparison of strength, and D is false. Common mistake: saying humans “came from modern monkeys” instead of recognizing shared ancestors.
Unit 3 Check (Science) — Inside, Mixed, and Unfamiliar Practice
Inside independent: A garden program grows pea plants. In peas, the allele for tall plants (T) is dominant over the allele for short plants (t). Two tall plants, both Tt, are crossed. What fraction of the offspring is expected to be short? About how many of 40 seeds?
Answer: Tt × Tt gives TT, Tt, Tt, and tt, so 1 of 4 is expected to be short (tt). One-fourth of 40 is about 10 seeds. That is an expected value, not a guarantee for any one batch (Chapter 11).
Mixed: A mutation changes one DNA base in a gene inside a skin cell on a person’s arm. Can that mutation be passed to the person’s children? Explain.
Answer: No. Only mutations in reproductive cells (eggs, sperm, or the cells that make them) can be inherited. A change in a skin cell can be copied into that cell’s descendants in the skin, but it is not passed to offspring (Chapters 10 and 12).
Unfamiliar (GED-style): On an island, a drought leaves mostly large, hard seeds. Finches with deeper beaks crack them more easily and survive and reproduce more. Over several generations, average beak depth increases. Which explanation fits best? A. The drought caused every bird to mutate in the same way. B. Individual birds grew deeper beaks because they needed them and passed that change on. C. Natural selection: heritable variation in beak depth plus differences in survival and reproduction. D. Beak depth is not inherited, so the change must be random.
Answer: C. The population changes because birds that already had deeper beaks left more offspring. B describes inheriting a change acquired by need, A makes mutation directed and universal, and D contradicts the inherited pattern (Chapter 13).
Ready to move on: get all three right with your reasoning written out. If you miss one, go back to the chapter named in its answer. With three questions, our 80% study goal means all three, on your first try, without help.