Part 4 — GED ® Social Studies · Unit 5 — Colonial America and the Founding
Chapter 23 — From Confederation to the Early Republic
GED® test targets: USH.b.5, USH.b.2, USH.b.3, USH.b.4; SSP.8.a
Imagine several fictional work groups sharing a task while each controls its own supplies. If no common authority can secure contributions, agreements may be hard to carry out. That limited comparison helps explain the Articles of Confederation. It does not turn work assignments into sovereign states. The historical question is why Americans who feared concentrated power nevertheless decided their first national arrangement needed more muscle.
Before the Constitution
The Articles of Confederation created a union with a comparatively weak central government and substantial state autonomy. Congress could conduct diplomacy and war but depended on states for revenue rather than directly taxing individuals. There was no separate national executive comparable to the later presidency. Difficulty financing obligations and coordinating policy contributed to arguments for change. [S11]
Shays’ Rebellion in 1786–1787, involving debt-burdened farmers and resistance to courts in Massachusetts, made elites more worried about disorder and about whether the government could do its job. It was one influence, not the sole cause of the Constitutional Convention. Economic conflicts, interstate disputes, and competing theories of authority also mattered.
During framing and ratification
The 1787 convention produced a proposed replacement government. The Great Compromise combined population-based representation in the House with equal state representation in the Senate. The Three-Fifths Compromise counted three fifths of enslaved people for representation and direct-tax apportionment. It did not grant enslaved people three fifths of a vote or three fifths of personal rights. It increased slaveholding states’ representation while denying enslaved people political participation.
Federalists supported ratification and argued that the proposed structure could govern effectively while controlling abuses. Anti-Federalists feared excessive central power and inadequate rights protections. Those are historical coalition labels, not exact equivalents of today’s parties. The Federalist essays defended the proposed Constitution; opponents circulated their own arguments. Commitments to add a bill of rights helped ratification. [S12]
After the new government began
Washington’s presidency established practices for the new executive and confronted disputes over finance and authority. Alexander Hamilton favored policies including a national bank and stronger national economic coordination. Thomas Jefferson and allies worried about concentrated power and favored a different vision of agriculture and government. Emerging party conflict showed that disagreement did not disappear once the Constitution was adopted.
The Louisiana Purchase in 1803 greatly expanded U.S. claims to territory. Those claims did not mean Indigenous nations had willingly surrendered their lands. The War of 1812 involved maritime disputes with Britain, British interference with U.S. shipping and sailors, and conflict connected to expansion and Indigenous resistance. The war ended without a major territorial transfer between Britain and the United States, while Indigenous nations faced worsening pressures in its aftermath. [S23]
Completed paired argument
Original paraphrases of ratification positions, not historical quotations: Position A argues that a stronger national government can manage common problems while divided institutions restrain power. Position B argues that distant national officials may threaten liberty unless rights are explicitly protected.
Question: What do the positions share? A. Both address how government affects liberty. B. Both reject all government. C. Both demand hereditary monarchy. D. Both deny that institutional design matters.
Answer: A. Their disagreement concerns how liberty is best protected, not whether liberty matters at all. Identifying common ground makes the disagreement more precise. Position A emphasizes structure; Position B emphasizes explicit guarantees and the danger of distance.
Which development responds most directly to Position B’s concern? The adoption of the Bill of Rights. That answer connects a stated concern to a relevant response. It does not imply every Anti-Federalist concern disappeared or every Federalist opposed amendments. People on the same side still disagreed with each other. A good label helps you sort the mess without pretending it is simple.
Second Look — A Stronger Union Came With Bargains and Costs
The Articles created a union with a weak national center dependent on states for major resources. Debt, interstate disputes, trade problems, and doubts about effective national action fueled demands for change. Fear of distant authority remained powerful after independence. The debate was not simply smart people against stupid people; it involved genuine disagreements over security, liberty, representation, and who would benefit from a stronger government.
Federalists argued the proposed Constitution offered workable government and internal safeguards. Anti-Federalists feared concentrated authority and insufficient explicit protections. The promise and later adoption of the Bill of Rights addressed important concerns without eliminating every disagreement. Ratification was a political struggle, not a unanimous room nodding wisely at a finished masterpiece. The bargaining is part of how the damn system developed.
Early disputes over finance, implied powers, foreign relations, and federal-state authority showed that adoption did not settle interpretation. On a GED paired-source question, find each side’s worry and the response that most directly answers it. A bill of rights answers fears about protected liberties differently from a taxing power answering revenue problems. Match the mechanism to the problem instead of treating every founding compromise as interchangeable.
Official Target Spotlight — George Washington (USH.b.3)
Washington could have hung on to power. He walked away after two terms, and that set the rule for everyone after him until Franklin Roosevelt won four elections and the country wrote the limit into law. George Washington commanded the Continental Army in the Revolution, presided over the Constitutional Convention in 1787, and served as the first president (1789–1797). He set lasting precedents: he formed a cabinet of advisers, kept the country neutral in the war between Britain and France (Proclamation of Neutrality, 1793), used federal force to end the Whiskey Rebellion (1794), and stepped down after two terms. His Farewell Address (1796) warned against political factions and permanent foreign alliances.
Practice: Washington left office after two terms. Which later change turned that custom into law? A. The Twelfth Amendment. B. The Twentieth Amendment. C. The Twenty-Fifth Amendment. D. The Twenty-Second Amendment.
Answer: D. The Twenty-Second Amendment (1951) limits a person to being elected president twice. A changed how electors vote for president and vice president, C covers presidential disability and succession, and B moved the dates when terms begin.
Official Target Spotlight — Thomas Jefferson (USH.b.4)
Jefferson preached a small, strict government, then bought a territory that doubled the country when the deal showed up. Thomas Jefferson wrote the main draft of the Declaration of Independence (1776) and served as the third president (1801–1809). The election of 1800 moved power peacefully from the Federalists to Jefferson’s Democratic-Republicans. Jefferson usually read the Constitution strictly, yet in 1803 he approved the Louisiana Purchase from France, which roughly doubled the size of the country even though the Constitution did not mention buying land. He then sent Lewis and Clark to explore the West. Jefferson also enslaved more than 600 people over his lifetime, a contradiction historians weigh against his words about equality.
Practice: Which action created the most tension with Jefferson’s strict reading of the Constitution? A. Drafting the Declaration of Independence. B. Approving the Louisiana Purchase. C. Sending Lewis and Clark to explore the West. D. Winning the election of 1800.
Answer: B. The Constitution did not clearly give the federal government power to buy territory. A came before the Constitution existed, C explored land without stretching the Constitution the way buying it did, and D was a peaceful election under the existing rules.
Official Target Spotlight — The War of 1812 (USH.b.2)
Anybody who has waited on mail gets this one: a war kept going after the peace deal was signed because the news hadn’t arrived yet. The War of 1812 (1812–1815) was fought between the United States and Great Britain. Causes included British impressment (forcing American sailors into the British navy), British trade restrictions during its war with France, and conflict on the western frontier, where Britain backed some Native nations resisting U.S. expansion. British troops burned Washington, D.C., in 1814. The Treaty of Ghent, signed in December 1814, largely restored prewar borders. Andrew Jackson’s victory at New Orleans came in January 1815, after the treaty was signed but before the news crossed the Atlantic. The war boosted American nationalism and weakened Native resistance.
Practice: The Battle of New Orleans was fought after the Treaty of Ghent was signed. What best explains this? A. The treaty required one final battle. B. Jackson’s victory forced Britain to sign. C. Britain had rejected the treaty. D. News of the treaty traveled slowly across the Atlantic.
Answer: D. Word of the treaty took weeks to arrive by ship. A and C are false, and B reverses the order of events: the treaty was signed before the battle.
Your Turn — Guided and Independent Practice — Practice Check SS23
Guided: Explain why weaknesses in the Articles of Confederation contributed to the Constitutional Convention and name one major constitutional compromise.
Guided answer: The national government lacked reliable taxing power, struggled to regulate interstate and foreign commerce, and depended heavily on states. The Constitution created stronger federal institutions. Compromises included the Great Compromise over congressional representation and the Three-Fifths Compromise protecting slave-state power.
Independent: Which debate produced a bicameral Congress with equal state representation in the Senate and population-based representation in the House? A. Missouri Compromise. B. Great Compromise. C. Compromise of 1877. D. New Deal.
Independent answer: B. The others occurred in later historical settings. Common mistake: calling every compromise a fair solution; some preserved deep injustice.
Unit 5 Check (Social Studies) — Inside, Mixed, and Unfamiliar Practice
Inside independent: Someone in a GED class says, “The Revolution was only about tea.” Give two other grievances or ideas behind independence.
Answer: Colonists objected to taxes passed by a Parliament where they had no representatives, and to British policies they saw as violating their rights. The Declaration of Independence also argued that governments get their just powers from the consent of the governed (Chapter 22).
Mixed: The Declaration of Independence was adopted in 1776, and the Bill of Rights was ratified in 1791. How many years apart are they? Name one document from between those dates.
Answer: 1791 − 1776 = 15 years. The Articles of Confederation (effective 1781) and the Constitution (signed 1787) both come between them (Chapters 22 and 23).
Unfamiliar (GED-style): Which was a major weakness of the national government under the Articles of Confederation? A. States had no powers of their own. B. The president had too much power. C. The Supreme Court struck down too many laws. D. Congress depended on the states for revenue instead of taxing individuals directly.
Answer: D. Congress could not directly tax individuals, so it depended on contributions from the states. B and C are wrong because the Articles had no national executive or court comparable to later ones, and A reverses the problem (Chapter 23).
Unfamiliar (GED-style): Anti-Federalists feared a strong central government. Which change most directly answered their concern? A. Giving the president a lifetime term. B. Abolishing the states. C. Ending elections. D. Adding the Bill of Rights.
Answer: D. The Bill of Rights added written protections against federal overreach. A, B, and C would have increased central power, not limited it (Chapter 23).
Ready to move on: get all four right with your reasoning written out. If you miss one, go back to the chapter named in its answer. With four questions, our 80% study goal means all four, on your first try, without help.
Unit 5 source notes: Colonial, revolutionary, and early national context draws on Library of Congress primary-source timeline collections [S21–S23]. Founding documents and ratification arguments use [S4–S5, S11–S12]. Instructional summaries and paraphrases are identified as such and are not invented historical quotations.