Part 4 — GED ® Social Studies · Unit 11 — The United States and the World
Chapter 43 — Putting Sources, Maps, and Numbers Together
GED® test targets: G.c.3; SSP.6.a–SSP.6.c, SSP.10.a–SSP.10.c, SSP.11.a
A fictional maintenance notice promises faster repairs. A work log lists completed jobs. Residents describe continuing problems. Those sources need not be direct contradictions: they may concern promises, output, and experiences during different periods. Before calling somebody a liar, line up dates, definitions, and scope. This is how combined GED source questions work. The hard part is not fancy vocabulary. It is keeping one source from answering a question it was never equipped to answer.
Completed case one — Why divide power
Primary source A, U.S. Constitution, Article I, Section 1, 1787: “All legislative Powers herein granted shall be vested in a Congress of the United States, which shall consist of a Senate and House of Representatives.” [S5]
Primary source B, James Madison, Federalist No. 51, 1788: “If men were angels, no government would be necessary. If angels were to govern men, neither external nor internal controls on government would be necessary.” [S12]
Both excerpts are supplied in full for this example’s questions; neither is the full original document. Source A is constitutional text establishing an institution. Source B is a persuasive essay supporting ratification and explaining a rationale for restraints. They are different kinds of writing with different purposes.
Question 1: What does Source A explicitly establish? It places the legislative powers granted by the Constitution in a two-chamber Congress. The phrase herein granted limits the statement to granted powers; it does not say Congress has every imaginable power.
Question 2: What inference does Source B support? Because people and officials are fallible, government requires controls. The angels comparison is figurative reasoning, not a claim that supernatural officials actually govern.
Question 3: Which conclusion connects the sources without overclaiming? Institutional design can distribute authority while reflecting concern about the misuse of power. Source A alone does not explain every reason for bicameralism, and Source B alone does not list all constitutional checks. A strong combined answer states a connection both can support.
Question 4: What is a relevant limitation? Madison was advocating ratification. That purpose helps explain his emphasis on the proposed system’s safeguards. It does not automatically make his argument false. To evaluate it further, compare the institutional design, opposing arguments, and evidence of how the system operates.
Completed case two — Read a political cartoon

Figure 6 — Original instructional cartoon about a fictional public budget
The original cartoon shows a large bag labeled CAMPAIGN PROMISES resting on one side of a balance scale. A smaller bag labeled AVAILABLE REVENUE sits on the other. A figure labeled TAXPAYER asks, “What pays for the difference?” The promises side hangs lower. This is a fictional instructional cartoon, not an archival image or a depiction of a real party.
Question: What is the cartoonist’s likely criticism? A. Every public service should end. B. Promises may exceed the resources identified to fund them. C. Taxpayers literally carry giant bags. D. A specific official has committed a crime.
Answer: B. The unequal bags and the question work together to criticize unfunded promises. A and D go beyond the image. C mistakes symbolism for literal reporting. A scale can symbolize balance, fairness, or comparison; the labels and caption determine which meaning fits here.
The cartoon is evidence of a viewpoint, not a financial audit. To establish whether a particular budget is underfunded, a reader would need actual revenue, spending, and financing records. A picture can raise a good question without giving you the data to answer it. The same goes for photographs: what is in the frame can be real while important context is left out.
Completed case three — A regional development claim
Original fictional regional report: “Towns with shorter trips to the freight terminal tend to have more manufacturing jobs per 1,000 residents. The report compares five towns in one year. It does not measure worker education, land costs, or tax incentives.”
| Town | Road distance to terminal | Manufacturing jobs per 1,000 residents |
|---|---|---|
| A | 10 km | 90 |
| B | 20 km | 80 |
| C | 30 km | 65 |
| D | 40 km | 60 |
| E | 50 km | 45 |

Figure 7 — Distance and manufacturing employment in fictional towns
The scatterplot places road distance on the horizontal axis and jobs per 1,000 residents on the vertical axis. Each point represents one town and two measured variables. The pattern shows a negative association: as distance increases, the employment measure generally decreases. Negative here just means the direction, not that something is bad.
Question 1: Does the plot prove that moving a terminal causes a particular increase in jobs? No. It shows association in five towns at one time. Other variables are unmeasured, and the location of the terminal itself may reflect earlier industrial development.
Question 2: What is the mean employment measure across these five towns? (90 + 80 + 65 + 60 + 45) ÷ 5 = 340 ÷ 5 = 68 jobs per 1,000 residents. This unweighted mean treats each town equally; it is not automatically the region’s population-weighted employment rate.
Question 3: What is the median? The ordered values are 45, 60, 65, 80, 90, so the median is 65. The range is 90 − 45 = 45. There is no mode because no value repeats.
Question 4: What would be a reasonable estimate for a similar town 25 kilometers away if the observed local pattern continued? A value between the nearby 20- and 30-kilometer observations, such as about 72.5 jobs per 1,000, would be an interpolation. It is an estimate, not a measured result. Predicting a negative number of jobs for a town hundreds of kilometers away by extending the same line would be unreasonable extrapolation.
Question 5: Which added evidence would improve causal analysis? Comparable observations over time, information about other relevant differences, and a design examining changes connected to terminal access. Merely adding a more confident title would improve nothing.
The finished reasoning habit
Across government, history, economics, and geography, the steps stay the same: identify the question, inspect the source, define the terms in context, read the display’s units, perform the needed calculation, and match the conclusion to the evidence. Then check what remains unknown.
You do not have to know every historical fact before you can reason well. You do need enough context to recognize what the source is about and enough discipline to avoid replacing evidence with assumptions. Read the word actually printed. Keep the denominator. Notice the date. Separate a promise from a result. That is the work—and it is work you can learn to do.
Make the Sources Work Together Without Making Stuff Up
Start by translating the question into the relationship it asks about: cause, comparison, change over time, perspective, or strength of evidence. Then identify each source’s author or producer, date, purpose, and measurement. A primary source comes from the period or participants being studied; a secondary source analyzes or interprets earlier material. Primary does not mean unbiased, and secondary does not mean unreliable. Corroboration means checking whether sources that did not copy each other agree. Two articles repeating the same unverified statement are not two independent confirmations.
Consider a fully worked fictional case: a city report says transit use rose from 20,000 to 24,000 trips after a new route opened. The increase is 4,000 trips, or 4,000 ÷ 20,000 × 100 = 20%. A map shows the new route serves a growing neighborhood. Together they make a connection believable, but they cannot separate the route’s effect from population growth, fares, jobs, or other changes. A survey of riders can add reported reasons, though it may omit people who stopped riding or never rode.
To evaluate an argument, separate its claim, evidence, and reasoning. The claim is the conclusion; evidence supplies observations or records; reasoning explains why the evidence supports that conclusion. An assumption is a needed premise that may not be stated. In the transit case, giving the route credit for all the growth assumes nothing else caused any of it. That is a big-ass assumption, not a tiny technicality. A well-supported answer may be narrower than an attractive answer that overclaims.
When choosing among answers, reject options that change the denominator, reverse cause and effect, ignore a source’s date, generalize beyond the population studied, or turn a correlation into proof. Pick the option that the evidence from every needed source backs up. Uncertainty is not the same as knowing nothing: you can establish that use increased while remaining uncertain about how much the route caused. That is serious reasoning. You are not looking for the loudest conclusion; you are looking for the one that can survive having its receipts checked.
Official Target Spotlight — Two Variables on a Graph (SSP.10.b)
A graph with two variables is asking one question: when this one moves, does that one follow? When a graph compares two variables, the independent variable is the one that changes on its own or is changed on purpose; it usually goes on the horizontal (x) axis. The dependent variable responds and usually goes on the vertical (y) axis. In a scatterplot of years of schooling and average income, years of schooling is independent and income is dependent. A pattern between them shows correlation; it does not by itself prove causation.
Practice: A study graphs average yearly rainfall and corn harvested per acre. Which is the dependent variable? A. Average yearly rainfall. B. Corn harvested per acre. C. The number of farms in the state. D. The year the study was printed.
Answer: B. The harvest responds to rainfall. A is the independent variable, and C and D are not variables in this graph.
Your Turn — Guided and Independent Practice — Practice Check SS43
Guided: A passage supports a new transit route, a map shows underserved neighborhoods, and a table shows projected cost and ridership. Build a conclusion using one fact from each source and name one limitation.
Guided answer: A defensible conclusion might say the route could improve access in underserved areas and is projected to serve a stated number of riders at a stated cost. A limitation is that projections are not actual outcomes and may depend on assumptions about demand, construction, or operating funds.
Independent: A timeline places a law before a court decision, while a source claims the decision caused the earlier law. What is the strongest criticism? A. The chronology makes that causal claim impossible as stated. B. Timelines never matter. C. Courts cannot affect laws. D. Earlier events have no causes.
Independent answer: A. Causes must precede effects. B ignores chronological reasoning, C is too absolute, and D is nonsense. Common mistake: combining sources by copying each one separately instead of making them answer the same question.
Unit 11 Check (Social Studies) — Inside, Mixed, and Unfamiliar Practice
Inside independent: A news report on the dayroom TV says several countries signed a treaty to reduce pollution in a river they share. Why might countries use a treaty instead of acting alone?
Answer: Pollution crosses borders, so one country acting alone cannot solve it. A treaty sets shared commitments, but because countries are sovereign, it depends on their agreement and on how well it is enforced (Chapter 42).
Mixed: A country’s yearly emissions fall from 500 million tons to 450 million tons after it signs the treaty. What is the percent decrease? Does the drop prove the treaty caused it?
Answer: (500 − 450) ÷ 500 × 100 = 10 percent. No. The timing fits, but an economic slowdown, new technology, or other policies could also explain the drop (Chapter 43).
Unfamiliar (GED-style): Which statement about Athenian democracy is accurate? A. Eligible male citizens took part directly in decisions, but women, enslaved people, and foreigners were excluded. B. All adults could vote. C. Voters chose representatives to make every law. D. Athens and Sparta shared one government.
Answer: A. Athens allowed direct participation by eligible male citizens only. B ignores who was excluded, C describes representative democracy, and D is false because Greek city-states were independent (Chapter 41).
Unfamiliar (GED-style): After the September 11, 2001, attacks, which new federal institution was created? A. The Supreme Court. B. The United Nations. C. The Federal Reserve. D. The Department of Homeland Security.
Answer: D. The Department of Homeland Security was created as part of the domestic response. A, B, and C already existed long before 2001 (Chapter 42).
Ready to move on: get all four right with your reasoning written out. If you miss one, go back to the chapter named in its answer. With four questions, our 80% study goal means all four, on your first try, without help.
Unit 11 source notes: Classical and environmental comparisons use [S54–S55]. International institutions and post-September 11 history use [S56–S60]. The paired primary excerpts use [S5, S12]. The cartoon, regional report, map-related statements, and data displays are original teaching materials.